Hip drop confusion crept into Saturday night time’s Raiders-Eels conflict with what appeared an apparent offence from Parramatta centre Bailey Simonsson not punished by a sin bin.
With 4 minutes to go within the first half, Simonsson produced what appeared a hip drop deal with on Raiders winger and former teammate Jordan Rapana.
The referee – having been given a message from the bunker – stopped play and positioned the Eel on report however opted to not ship him to the bin.
Watch each recreation of each spherical of the 2023 NRL Telstra Premiership Season LIVE on Kayo Sports. New to Kayo? Start your free trial now >
FOX LEAGUE PODCAST – INSIDE MAGIC ROUND
Eight video games over three days within the one location — What does Magic Round seem like from the media’s perspective? Stories from the successful and shedding sheds, the opposite aspect of Wayne Bennett nobody sees, a fuming Craig Bellamy and the NRL’s new cult determine. Listen right here >
Michael Ennis labelled the choice as “madness” after Dan Ginnane posed the query “have we had a change of interpretation here?”
“The fact that he lands on the back of the legs, the referees have seen a number of angles. It’s enough to tell the referee in his earpiece that it’s a hip drop yet he doesn’t go to the sin bin?” Ennis stated.
“How do the fans, the Brisbane fans sitting at home tonight (feel)? It’s madness, honestly.”
”Hello to Patrick Carrigan watching on,” Ginnane added.
The incident Ginnane and Ennis referenced was the sin binning of Broncos lock Pat Carrigan for a hip drop towards the Storm on Thursday night time, a deal with which most would believed wasn’t as unhealthy as Simonsson’s.
Eels coach Brad Arthur, who let rip on the match officers after his group’s 26-18 loss, says Simonsson shouldn’t have even been penalised.
Horsburgh sin binned after Matterson hit | 00:47
MORE NRL NEWS
‘HARD TO ROLL AWAY’: Dragons cop ‘tough’ sin bin in match turning second
CASUALTY WARD: Roosters cop triple harm blow as Walker’s absence defined
‘INCREDIBLE LESSON’: Roosters ‘bitten pretty hard’ as Robbo takes the blame
Asked if there have been any particular calls that stood out as notably egregious, he stated: “Hip drop.”
The reporter adopted up, asking whether or not Arthur was saying he thought it wasn’t a hip drop. Arthur replied: “No.”
Earlier within the half, one other ugly incident unfolded when Junior Paulo was the third man in on a deal with on Joseph Tapine which injured the Raiders star.
“Ooh that’s an ugly angle,” Ginnane stated.
“Some at home might be saying we’ve had some questionable hip drops that have been far less damaging than that and have resulted in ten in the bin.
“It looks like penalty and just the report for Paulo. That might have Freddy Fittler a little worried there, as we get closer to Origin.”
Get all the newest NRL news, highlights and evaluation delivered straight to your inbox with Fox Sports Sportmail. Sign up now!!
“Geez, I don’t like the look of that. There’s no real force, he didn’t spear in, but he’s a big man Junior. There’s some real weight into the lower leg there,” Michael Ennis added.
Arthur additionally believed there was nothing on this incident, saying he’d be stunned if Paulo would cop additional punishment from the judiciary.
“Yeah 100%. There was nothing in it,” Arthur stated.
“It’s not a cannonball. There’s no force in it whatsoever. None.”
Source: www.foxsports.com.au